Manto as a Moral Artist in Mumtaz Shirin's Criticism: Text Based Study

ممتاز شیریں کی تنقید میں منٹو ایک اخلاقی فنکار: متن اساس مطالعہ

Authors

  • Dr. Sumaira Malik Ph.D. Urdu , Department of Urdu, NUML, Islamabad Author
  • Dr. Zafar Ahmed Assistant Professor, Department of Urdu, NUML, Islamabad Author

Keywords:

Text-Based Criticism, Mumtaz Shirin, Saadat Hassan Manto, New Criticsm, Female Critics, Moral Artist, Manto Noori na Naari

Abstract

Text Based Criticism is a literary approach that focuses on detailed analysis of a work's qualities, both positive and negative regardless of its external factors. This type of criticism examines the inherent merits and flaws of a text, exploring its virtues and vices and the underlying causes for these characteristics. It establishes a relationship between the work and the reader, helping to interpret the meaning and significance of the text. Mumtaz Shirin is highly regarded, especially among female critics, for her contributions to Urdu literary criticism. Among the prominent critics in Urdu literature, Shirin stands out, particularly for her in-depth studies of Saadat Hassan Manto's works. In her essays, she meticulously analyzed Manto's political, moral, and social ideas, which were central themes in his writings, especially in his short stories. In this article, an attempt is made to draw basic conclusions after text-based study of Shirin’s essays on Manto.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Qazi Afzal Hussain, Tahreer Asaas Tanqeed, Educational Book House, Aligarh, P. 19

Ibid., P. 20

Ibid., P. 20

Nasir Abbas Nayyar, Matan Siyaaq aur Tanazur, Poorab Academy, Islamabad, 2012, P. 15

Stephen Popp, Bahwala Nasir Abbas Nayyar, Matan Siyaaq aur Tanazur, P. 5

Ibid., P. 33

Abid Ali Abid, Professor, Usool-e-Intiqad-e-Adabiyat, Sang-e-Meel Publications, Lahore, 1997, P. 115

Jameel Jalbi, Dr.,(Translator), Arastu se Eliot tak, National Book Foundation, Islamabad, 1985, P. 17

Mumtaz Shirin, Manto Noori Na Naari, Maktaba Asloob, Karachi, 1985, P. 22

Ibid., P. 134

Ibid., P. 142

Ibid., P. 55

Downloads

Published

30-12-2025

How to Cite

Dr. Sumaira Malik, and Dr. Zafar Ahmed. “Manto As a Moral Artist in Mumtaz Shirin’s Criticism: Text Based Study: ممتاز شیریں کی تنقید میں منٹو ایک اخلاقی فنکار: متن اساس مطالعہ”. Tashkeel, vol. 3, no. 2, Dec. 2025, pp. 44-57, https://tashkeel.uoj.edu.pk/index.php/tashkeel/article/view/46.